<2c0e02830703271340n4193a16ei42dcdd672748804f@mail.gmail.com>
Current votes: None.
Hi Dave, On 3/28/07, Dave Singer <singer@apple.com> wrote: > >> We really feel that the HTML spec. should say no more about video and > >> audio formats than it does about image formats (which is merely to give > >> examples), and we should strive independently for audio/video > >> convergence. We'd really like to discuss the 'meat' of the proposal -- > >> the tags, the CSS, and so on! > > > >The whole point of the spec is to make sure implementations are > >compatible. Just discussing the "meat" and ignoring how things work out > >in practice may backfire. > > I think the example of SVG (a 'markup' language) having a codec > requirement that 3GPP then had to explicitly write-out is > instructive. The attempt there didn't work. I would be curious for the reasons that 3GPP has taken the requirement of vorbis out of the spec. Was that a decision based on technical reasons and could you please explain what these technical reasons were? Regards, Silvia.